English
 Supplier sign in
Home
STAY INFORMED
Subscribe to our monthly newsletter.
Your email address will never be disclosed to any third party.
Read our privacy notice.

       

Specialist article
17.12.2020  |  1233x
Share this item

The importance of the Tensile Strength of powders

Tensile Strength is the prime component of cohesion, which has many adverse consequences, especially in small scale, as in pharmaceutical applications
Great emphasis is directed to securement of measured values of the flow properties of bulk materials because of the need to design storage, process and handling equipment that provides reliable performance. Until the 1960’s the design of bulk storage equipment depended largely on empirical experience because of the lack of a scientific understanding of the behaviour in bulk of particulate materials. From a background in soil mechanics, [1], hopper design parameters were established in the 1960’s based on the measurement of bulk density, wall friction and shear strength values. [2].

This initiated industrial, academic and Government interest in the benefits that industry may gain from a scientific approach to the subject of bulk technology with seminars, conferences, exhibitions, magazines and specialised courses springing up all over the world. Shear plane length limitations of the Jenike call were overcome by annular cells, [3], [4], [5]. Interest in the dynamic behaviour of powder led to the introduction of the Freeman rheometer, [6]. This measures the torque of rotating a blade through a sample and enables some comparative value to be gained, a phenomenon based approach to bulk behaviour. The important quest remains for quantifying basic bulk strength mechanisms, of which tensile strength is probably the most fundamental.
Tensile strength versus consolidation load
Tensile strength versus consolidation load

Cohesion and shear resistance

Flow difficulties are often attributed to cohesion, being a reluctance of a bulk material to shear in the absence of a normal stress on the material. Cohesion is actually a consequence of tensile strength, being the origin of the force that is being applied between the members concerned. Shear resistance then develops due to the mechanical overlapping of particles in the shearing plane and the inter-particle friction between the particles.

Fundamental properties

Developments in the subject formed part of Harold Wilson’s ‘White heat of technology’ in the late 1960’s and 70’s. The British Materials Handling Board was set up by the UK Government to unify university and industrial research and Warren Spring Laboratories to carry out pioneering work on examining the fundamental properties of loose solids. Tensile strength was identified as a basic feature influencing the behaviour of bulk materials, being responsible for cohesion, as the resistance to shear developed by tensile forces acting normal to the sharing surface. WSL constructed devices for measuring tensile strength and cohesion that were later developed into commercially available instruments, [7], [8]. The tensile strength of a powder compact can have many values, according to the nature of the particle and the level of stress applied.

Three times tensile strength


There are also three classes of tensile strength, according to how the consolidation stress is applied and the direction in which it is measured.
  • The most fundamental is where the bulk is separated in a reverse direction to the applied compacting stress, the separation force reflecting those generated normal to the contact surface. Apart from being awkward to measure due to the difficulty of gripping a sample it is of low interest as is rarely relevant to commercial applications.
  • More relevant to flow situations is where failure takes place at 900 to the consolidating stress. This is the weakest form of tensile strength due to the formation stress being a consequence of the minimum principle stress of consolidation. This is the form measured by WSL type instruments.
  • A third, much less common class of tensile strength, is the rarer circumstances of failure in a tri-axially consolidated sample, where the direction of separation is irrelevant.

Tensile forces also develop on boundary contact surfaces and become a factor to add to normal forces that develop frictional resistance to slip in hopper, chutes and flow boundary surfaces. They show in wall friction graphs of normal load/ wall friction as a positive value contact load at zero applied normal load. And is often attributed to a variation on contact friction with stress.
Ajax Linear Tensile Tester
Ajax Linear Tensile Tester
Ajax Linear Tensile Tester
Ajax Linear Tensile Tester


All these values are dependent on numerous variables, so the conditions under which they are measured must be related to the operating circumstances of interest. The formation and operating stresses that apply to bulk density and wall friction can usually be determined when time is taken into account, but the bulk strength is dependent on a combination of the mechanical and physical properties of the bulk material in variable ambient and operating conditions according to both the prevailing stress and the stress history of the material.

Packing arrangement

The question arises, ‘What are the underlying, fundamental properties of a bulk material that influence how it will deform and flow?’ These clearly arise from the nature of the particles of composition and the forces acting on them. It can be seen that relative movement of particles in contact will involve both structural interference on the overlapping members and surface interactions on the particle contact surfaces. Attractive forces between particles depend upon how close they are together. The state of packing arrangement is therefore important, so measured values should reflect the operating conditions of interest.

Changes in packing state results in changes in density, void volume and porosity. Bulk expansion for flow creates a temporary differential pressure between the voids and ambient that applies a compressive stress on the bulk that supplement tensile forces that may be present to appose flow.
Particulate solids in a settled condition inevitable nest in packing with a degree of particle overlap. To allow relative motion along the shearing layer it is necessary for local overlapping members to either fracture or move apart and reordering their structure in adjacent layers. Local expansion of the bulk can only take place In confined circumstances at the expense of compaction of the adjacent mass or lifting of the bed. This will be firmly resisted by the passive stress of a settled structure of firm particles. Forces acting during the initiation of flow may therefore be considerably higher that those which are acting is steady state flow conditions. This mechanical resistance to the initiation of flow can be the major element of the resisting force, depending on the size, shape and strength of the particles.

Surface forces

The strength of forces acting on a surface contact depends on many factors which result in a combined value. They may arise from molecular forces as Van der Waal or electrostatic, chemical affinity, sintering, magnetic, fusion, bonding or ‘caking’ A major variable value is moisture content that forms liquid bridges and high surface tension forces. Resistance to separation can also arise from the mechanical interlocking of laminated flakes or fibrous products or the partial vacuum in the voids due to the demand of flow expansion of products that have low permeability. Tensile strength must therefore be measured as a single, unified force.
It is clear that tensile strength represents an important and basic factor in the flow potential of a bulk material. This force can have a significant influence on how a bulk material behaves, especially for powders with particles less than 50 microns.

Summary

Tensile strength is important, not only at high degrees of compaction and stress, as it increases the bulk strength of the mass at a low stress levels and ‘competes’ against the relatively low force of gravity. For an understanding of overall bulk solids behaviour it is necessary to appreciate the contribution and effects of the tensile strength of a particle array. It is the prime component of cohesion, which has many adverse consequences, hence is useful as a classification of flow potential and gives a direct, fundamental measure of the potential difficulties that cohesion causes. It is especially relevant in small scale, low applied stress conditions with low density materials that are often found in the pharmaceutical industry.


References

[1] Hvorslev, M. J. 1936 ‘A ring shearing apparatus for the determination of the shearing resistance and plastic flow of soil’. In Proc. Intl Conf. Soil Mech. Found. Eng, Cambridge, Mass, vol. 2, pp.125–129.
[2] Jenike ‘Flow of solids’, Bull 123 University of Utah experimental station. Vol 53, No.26, Nov.1964
[3] Walker.D.M, annular cell. CEGB. Portishead. Power Technology Vol 1. No.4.1968. ’An annular shear cell for granular materials’.
[4] Schulze annular shear cell. Ring Shear Tester RST-XS.s. Dr. Dietmar Schulze Schüttgutmesstechnik, Am Forst 20, 38302 Wolfenbüttel, Germany
[5] Brookfield annular cell. Brookfield Engineering Laboratories, Inc. 11 Commerce Blvd., Middleboro, Massachusetts 02346 U.S.
[6] FT4 Freeman rheometer. Freeman Technology. 1 Miller Court, Severn Drive, Tewkesbury, GL20 8DN.
[7] Ajax cohesion tester. Ajax Equipment Ltd. Mule Street, Bolton, BL2 2AR.
[8] Ajax tensile tester. Ajax Equipment Ltd. Mule Street, Bolton, BL2 2AR


Company information

More items

Glossary of Terms in Powder and Bulk Technology  An explanation of terms relating to particle technology as an introductory tool for non-specialists, newcomers and students in the field.
Glossary of Terms in Powder and Bulk Technology
An explanation of terms relating to particle technology as an introductory tool for non-specialists, newcomers and students in the field. Bulk solids play a vital role in human society, permeating almost all industrial activities and dominating many. Bulk technology embraces many disciplines, yet does not fall within the domain of a specific professional activity such as mechanical or chemical engineering. The British Materials Handling Board perceived the need for a Glossary of Terms in Particle Technology as an introductory tool for non-specialists, newcomers and students in this subject. The glossary was prepared by Lyn Bates for The British Materials Handling Board (BMHB). It contains an Introduction, with 3 paragraphs: Bulk solids in industry; Rand Reports on the performance of plants that handle bulk solids; and General terms. Sections of terms Then term in the glossary are grouped in the following sections: Types of Powder, Powder Properties, Powder Processing, Particle Properties, Particle Size, Particle Shape, Pore Size and Shape, Particle Surface Area, Particle Test Methods (of Image
14.12.2020  |  1244x  |  White paper  | 
Matching feeder extraction pattern with hoppers Hopper design is primarily based on the nature and physical properties of the material to be stored, but the feeder is also very important.
Matching feeder extraction pattern with hoppers
Hopper design is primarily based on the nature and physical properties of the material to be stored, but the feeder is also very important. The criteria for hopper design are primarily based on the nature and physical properties of the material to be stored. The first decision is to choose an appropriate flow regime, Generally - mass flow is selected for products that deteriorate over time, funnel flow for inert, free flowing materials and expanded flow for poor flow, inert contents. [1]. This step determines the slope of the hopper walls in relation to the wall friction value. The minimum hopper outlet size depends on the shear strength of the material and outlet shape. [2]. Consideration has to be given to products that segregate of fluidise to ensure that their discharged condition is suitable for further processing and ultimate use. Plane flow from ’V’ shape of hopper sections offers benefits for flow and capacity over radial flow in conical shaped hoppers, but requires a feeder to extract from an outlet slot. Feeders play a crucial role in the performance of a hopper and form an integral
09.12.2020  |  1340x  |  Specialist article  | 

Related categories

PORTALS
BulkSolids-Portal Schuettgut-Portal Recycling-Portal
Related
Bulkgids.nl
SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER
Newsletter archive
Service and contact
ContactDisclaimerPrivacyAdvertising
FOLLOW US
Linked